Allegiant ordered to pay $157K to former broker in case of forged Finra letter
An arbitration panel has awarded a former broker at Allegiant Securities LLC $100,000 in a case that arbitrators said involved a forged letter purporting to be from the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority Inc.
An arbitration panel has awarded a former broker at Allegiant Securities LLC $100,000 in a case that arbitrators said involved a forged letter purporting to be from the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority Inc.
Allegiant withheld commissions from Jay Weinstein, a broker at the firm, “based on a fraudulent claim that there was a Finra fine that had been levied against the firm,” said Brian Buckstein, the attorney who represented Mr. Weinstein.
A three-person Finra panel ruled recently that the president of Allegiant, “or someone under his direction or control, concocted a forged letter from Finra claiming that [Mr. Weinstein] was the subject of an ongoing investigation, which was false.”
In addition to the $100,000 award, which was formally issued late last month, Allegiant was ordered to pay Mr. Weinstein $57,500 in attorney’s fees and costs.
“We don’t know to this day who created” the phony letter, Mr. Buckstein said. “It’s the craziest document I’ve ever seen — it looks identical to a standard [investigatory] letter from Finra.”
Allegiant’s president, Dennis Flanagan, said he will attempt to have the award vacated.
We had nothing to do with” the forged Finra letter, he said.
“I had a contract” with Mr. Weinstein, Mr. Flanagan said. “I didn’t need a fake letter” to get paid the $11,000 Mr. Weinstein allegedly owed the firm.
The award was a “devastating blow to small firm like us that has never been in trouble,” he added.
A spokesman for Finra was not immediately available for comment.
The case began when Allegiant sued Mr. Weinstein for the money.
Mr. Weinstein counterclaimed, alleging defamation on his U-5 termination form.
The arbitration panel ordered removal of the defamatory information on Mr. Weinstein’s U-5.
Mr. Weinstein, who left Allegiant in June 2008, has since founded his own advisory firm, Independent Fiduciary Consultants LLC in Seattle.
He declined to comment about the case.
Learn more about reprints and licensing for this article.