Active or passive? It depends where you work

Active or passive? It depends where you work
Over the past two years, confidence in passive investing has grown mainly among RIAs while other advisers primarily remain active.
JUL 13, 2015
By  Ellie Zhu
When it comes to financial advisers, active vs. passive isn't really a debate about money management. It comes down to where they work. The fast growth of exchange-traded funds has sparked debate about everything from the rise of fee-based advisers to the wisdom of shunning active managers to the future of mutual funds. But a study released this week shows that actively managed mutual funds remain firmly at the center of the way financial advisers manage client money.

Mutual funds: the one thing most advisers use

Sources: Market Strategies International, Cogent Reports, Advisor Brandscape, June 2015.

The data is based on an annual Cogent Reports study that asked a representative sample of 1,390 U.S. advisers who manage more than $5 million how they allocate their clients' money. The 2015 data was collected from January to March.

On average, advisers put a third of client assets in mutual funds, but they've lost market share to ETFs

Source: Market Strategies International, Cogent Reports, Advisor Brandscape, June 2015.

This year, almost all RIAs sold ETFs

Source: Market Strategies International, Cogent Reports, Advisor Brandscape, June 2015.

Yet the study found that the substantial growth of ETFs, which now manage $3 trillion globally, has not been completely at the expense of active management, at least according to advisers. While ETFs generally track indexes, they can be traded actively.

RIAs put substantially more clients assets in passive investments in 2015

Source: Market Strategies International, Cogent Reports, Advisor Brandscape, June 2015.

But most advisers still kept more than two-thirds of their clients “active”

Source: Market Strategies International, Cogent Reports, Advisor Brandscape, June 2015.

Latest News

Stocks rise ahead of packed week of earnings, data
Stocks rise ahead of packed week of earnings, data

Four of the Magnificent Seven will report this week.

Gold down more than 5% in less than a week
Gold down more than 5% in less than a week

Easing anxiety has seen the haven asset slide from record high.

Bond managers grapple with multiple unanswered questions
Bond managers grapple with multiple unanswered questions

Uncertainty remains challenging for Treasuries traders.

Consumers facing higher costs as Chinese firms pass on tariff burden
Consumers facing higher costs as Chinese firms pass on tariff burden

Move will raise concerns of inflationary impact of tariffs.

Americans earning under $200K could pay less tax, or perhaps nothing says Trump
Americans earning under $200K could pay less tax, or perhaps nothing says Trump

President says tariffs could see income tax ‘completely eliminated’ for some

SPONSORED Compliance in real time: Technology's expanding role in RIA oversight

RIAs face rising regulatory pressure in 2025. Forward-looking firms are responding with embedded technology, not more paperwork.

SPONSORED Advisory firms confront crossroads amid historic wealth transfer

As inheritances are set to reshape client portfolios and next-gen heirs demand digital-first experiences, firms are retooling their wealth tech stacks and succession models in real time.