Stock market sell-off: Takeaways to share with clients

Those hoping the mini-crash will solve the active vs. passive debate will have to wait a bit longer. But advisers who touted the advantages of diversification have lots to crow about.
FEB 06, 2018

Those hoping that the stock market's recent tantrums will solve the active vs. passive debate will have to wait a bit longer. But advisers who touted the advantages of diversification will have lots to crow about to clients after this sell-off. The Standard & Poor's 500 stock index has fallen 6.66% from its January 26 high, according to Morningstar, Inc., and it fell 4.10% on Monday alone. Not surprisingly, that's pretty much what investors got from index funds that follow the S&P 500. The Vanguard 500 Index fund (VFINX), for example, fell 4.11% Monday and 6.67% since the market peak. From there however, things get murky — and a fund's performance during the market's recent unpleasantness depended on a variety of factors, one of which was its investment style. For example, the Vanguard Value Index fund (VIVAX) has fallen 6.86% since the market peak. The median large-company value fund — half higher, half lower — fell 6.93%. So by that measure, most large-cap value funds failed to beat the index. On the other hand, many of the most popular large value funds with advisers did beat the Vanguard Value Index fund. American Funds Washington Mutual (AWSHX), for example, fell 6.21%, while American Funds American Mutual (AMRMX) fell 5.60%. "The last bear market illustrated that value was misunderstood: People expected the manager to have brilliantly gone to all cash," said Russel Kinnel, Morningstar's director of manager research. That's unrealistic if the fund is always fully invested." Similarly, growth funds fared better than the S&P 500: Vanguard's Growth Index fund (VIGRX) lost 6.29% since the market's peak, while the median large-company growth fell 6.18%. American Funds Growth Fund of America (AGTHX), the biggest large-company growth fund, dropped 5.54%, while Fidelity Contrafund, in the number two slot, fell 5.91%. In part, growth funds may have held up better than value because earnings on tech stocks have held up better than those of bank stocks – a value favorite. In either event, however, active management has yet to prove that it can provide investors in a sell-off. "In theory, active management can respond to market sell off by either exiting positions when management has concerns and using cash to buy favored stocks selling at a discount to fair value," said Todd Rosenbluth, director of ETF & mutual fund research at CFRA. "Passive mutual funds and ETFs cannot do so and must track their index regardless. Unfortunately many active managers do not time the market correctly and to a degree greater than the premium fee their funds charge relative to index counterparts." Some smart beta ETFs did prove to shield investors against volatility, albeit mildly. For example, PowerShares S&P 500 Low Volatility ETF (SPLV) fell 3.59% Monday and 5.55% since the market peak. But again, the biggest factor for many factor funds was where they concentrated their bets. PowerShares S&P Small-Cap High Dividend (XSHD) fell just 3.33%, in part because small-cap stocks suffered less than large-cap stocks during the sell-off. In any event, it's good to remember that low costs may well be the largest factor in long-term outperformance for a fund. By and large, low-cost active funds fare better than high-cost ones.
Are we heading into a long-term market correction?
Source: InvestmentNews survey, 590 readers.

What really worked for investors? Diversification. Large-company value funds may have had bigger losses in the mini-meltdown, but those are the funds you want to own after a bear market. That point hasn't been reached yet, said Charlie Bobrinskoy, manager of Ariel Focus (ARFFX), which is up 3.88% for the year. "This is nothing like 2008, when we had great companies selling as seven times earnings." But beyond stock funds, diversification was golden. For example. Bond prices rose during the market's mini-meltdown, so a client who had Vanguard Total Bond Market Index (VBMFX) lost just 0.57% since the last market peak. PIMCO Income Institutional (VTBIX) fell 0.58%. Most international funds held up well because of the falling dollar – and, since the sell-off happened late in the day when foreign markets were closed, fair-value pricing may have helped as well, Mr. Kinnel said. And, of course, money funds didn't fall at all – which doesn't seem good in a bull market, but seems great during a bear market.

Latest News

Farther debuts AI investment proposal tool for advisors to win clients
Farther debuts AI investment proposal tool for advisors to win clients

"Im glad to see that from a regulatory perspective, we're going to get the ability to show we're responsible [...] we'll have a little bit more freedom to innovate," Farther co-founder Brad Genser told InvestmentNews.

Barred ex-Merrill Lynch advisor arrested in alleged $2.6M theft of former Miami Dolphin Pro Bowler
Barred ex-Merrill Lynch advisor arrested in alleged $2.6M theft of former Miami Dolphin Pro Bowler

Former advisor Isaiah Williams allegedly used the stolen funds from ex-Dolphins defensive safety Reshad Jones for numerous personal expenses, according to police and court records.

Are you optimally efficient?
Are you optimally efficient?

Taking a systematic approach to three key practice areas can help advisors gain confidence, get back time, and increase their opportunities.

Advisor moves: Father-son duo leaves Raymond James for LPL, RayJay adds Merrill Lynch alum in Florida
Advisor moves: Father-son duo leaves Raymond James for LPL, RayJay adds Merrill Lynch alum in Florida

Meanwhile, Osaic lures a high-net-worth advisor from Commonwealth in the Pacific Northwest.

Beacon Pointe adds six RIAs in two-month acquisition spree, boosting AUM by $2.7B
Beacon Pointe adds six RIAs in two-month acquisition spree, boosting AUM by $2.7B

The deals, which include its first stake in Ohio, push the national women-led firm up to $47 billion in assets.

SPONSORED How advisors can build for high-net-worth complexity

Orion's Tom Wilson on delivering coordinated, high-touch service in a world where returns alone no longer set you apart.

SPONSORED RILAs bring stability, growth during volatile markets

Barely a decade old, registered index-linked annuities have quickly surged in popularity, thanks to their unique blend of protection and growth potential—an appealing option for investors looking to chart a steadier course through today's choppy market waters, says Myles Lambert, Brighthouse Financial.