Finra arbitrators order Pershing to pay $648,543 to Stanford Ponzi victims

Finra arbitrators order Pershing to pay $648,543 to Stanford Ponzi victims
The ripped-off investors allege Pershing looked the other way when it serving as custodian and clear agent for the fraudster.
JUL 12, 2021

Finra arbitrators ordered Pershing to pay $648,543 to three victims of R. Allen Stanford’s Ponzi scheme.

The three-person, all-public panel ruled in a decision last Thursday that Pershing should have known that Stanford was perpetrating a massive investor rip-off when it served as the custodian and clearing firm for the Stanford Group Co.

Stanford was convicted in 2012 of committing a $7.2 billion fraud that revolved around selling certificates of deposit issued by his offshore bank, Stanford International Bank Ltd. in Antigua, and recommended by his firm’s financial advisers.

In the latest arbitration action involving Pershing's connection to Stanford, more than two dozen claimants in two consolidated cases alleged that Pershing “gave material assistance” to the Ponzi scheme “despite having concerns about the CDs and SGC.”

The Financial Industry Regulatory Authority Inc. arbitration panel held Pershing liable. But the arbitrators awarded compensatory damages only to three of the investors Charles A. Pope ($436,000); Joyce E. Cagel ($87,200); and the retirement account of Dudley Devore ($124,593).

“The panel finds that, based on all of the evidence and testimony presented, by the beginning of 2008, [Pershing] had the requisite level of knowledge, as to SGC’s wrongful conduct in connection with the CD scheme, that it knew or should have known that it was providing meaningful/substantial assistance to that wrongful scheme by remaining the clearing firm for SGC in the United States and, more particularly, by facilitating wire transfers for the purchase of CDs issued by SIBL on behalf of Charles A. Pope, Dudley Devore IRA, and Joyce E. Cagle during 2008,” the July 8 arbitration decision states.

The full roster of claimants requested $10.6 million in compensatory damages and $6.2 million in interest. One group filed their complaint in March 2020 and the other in November 2020.

Finra arbitrators rarely explain their decisions. Even though the panel laid out its reasoning for ruling against Pershing, it did not indicate why it denied awards for most of the claimants.  

Finra arbitrators previously awarded $5.6 million in February 2020 and $1.4 million in May 2019 to investors who filed similar arbitration claims against Pershing, which is a division of BNY Mellon.

A spokesperson for Pershing said the firm does not comment on legal matters. Lawyers for the investors were not immediately available for comment.

Latest News

Integrated Partners, Kestra welcome multigenerational advisor teams
Integrated Partners, Kestra welcome multigenerational advisor teams

Integrated Partners is adding a mother-son tandem to its network in Missouri as Kestra onboards a father-son advisor duo from UBS.

Trump not planning to fire Powell, market tension eases
Trump not planning to fire Powell, market tension eases

Futures indicate stocks will build on Tuesday's rally.

From stocks and economy to their own finances, consumers are getting gloomier
From stocks and economy to their own finances, consumers are getting gloomier

Cost of living still tops concerns about negative impacts on personal finances

Women share investing strengths, asset preferences in new study
Women share investing strengths, asset preferences in new study

Financial advisors remain vital allies even as DIY investing grows

Trump vows to 'be nice' to China, slash tariffs
Trump vows to 'be nice' to China, slash tariffs

A trade deal would mean significant cut in tariffs but 'it wont be zero'.

SPONSORED Compliance in real time: Technology's expanding role in RIA oversight

RIAs face rising regulatory pressure in 2025. Forward-looking firms are responding with embedded technology, not more paperwork.

SPONSORED Advisory firms confront crossroads amid historic wealth transfer

As inheritances are set to reshape client portfolios and next-gen heirs demand digital-first experiences, firms are retooling their wealth tech stacks and succession models in real time.